The Toyota Tacoma, a name synonymous with reliability and ruggedness, has been a staple in the midsize truck market for decades.
However, like any long-standing model, it has had its highs and lows. In this guide, I will get you through best and worst years of the Toyota Tacoma, providing you with stats, examples, and insights that will help you make an informed decision if you’re considering purchasing one.
Whether you’re a die-hard Tacoma fan or just curious about its history, this article is for you.
Personal Insight
As someone who’s spent countless hours under the hood and behind the wheel, my relationship with cars goes beyond mere appreciation; it’s a deep-rooted passion.
The Toyota Tacoma holds a special place in my heart. I remember the first time I test-drove a Tacoma, feeling the raw power and responsiveness that only a well-engineered machine can offer.
My days as a mechanic allowed me to see the intricacies of its design, the thoughtfulness in every component. It’s not just about the specs and performance figures; it’s about the stories, the adventures, and the memories created.
The Tacoma, with its rich history and undeniable legacy, is more than just a truck to me. It’s a testament to Toyota’s dedication to excellence, and a reminder of why I fell in love with cars in the first place.
Worst Toyota Tacoma Years
Worst Year: 2009 Toyota Tacoma (3.45 Rating)
The 2009 Tacoma was plagued with issues related to the radio and the clutch. Owners reported that the radio would randomly shut off or not work at all.
The clutch, on the other hand, had a tendency to wear out prematurely, leading to costly replacements. Additionally, there were reports of the engine stalling without warning.
- Common Issues:
- Radio malfunctions
- Clutch wearing out prematurely
- Engine stalling
Consumer Reviews, Ratings, Recalls & Complaints:
- NHTSA: 2009 Toyota Tacoma got 9 recalls and 312 complaints
- Edmunds: 2009 Toyota Tacoma got 4.3/5.0 consumer reviews
- Jd Power: 2009 Toyota Tacoma got 84/100 consumer ratings
- Kelley Blue Book: 2009 Toyota Tacoma got 4.6/5.0 consumer ratings
Worst Year: 2010 Toyota Tacoma (3.40 Rating)
The 2010 Tacoma faced significant issues with the transmission. Owners reported that the transmission would slip, causing the vehicle to jerk unexpectedly.
There were also complaints about the vehicle’s poor fuel economy and the air conditioning system not working properly.
- Common Issues:
- Transmission slipping
- Poor fuel economy
- Air conditioning malfunctions
Consumer Reviews, Ratings, Recalls & Complaints:
- NHTSA: 2010 Toyota Tacoma got 8 recalls and 290 complaints
- Edmunds: 2010 Toyota Tacoma got 4.5/5.0 consumer reviews
- Jd Power: 2010 Toyota Tacoma got 85/100 consumer ratings
- Kelley Blue Book: 2010 Toyota Tacoma got 4.6/5.0 consumer ratings
Worst Year: 2011 Toyota Tacoma (3.35 Rating)
Takes the top spot for the worst year due to a myriad of issues. The most significant problem was with the brakes. Owners reported that the brakes would fail without warning. There were also numerous complaints about the vehicle’s poor handling, especially in wet conditions.
- Common Issues:
- Brake failures
- Poor handling in wet conditions
- Electrical issues
Consumer Reviews, Ratings, Recalls & Complaints:
- NHTSA: 2011 Toyota Tacoma got 6 recalls and 278 complaints
- Edmunds: 2011 Toyota Tacoma got 4.4/5.0 consumer reviews
- Jd Power: 2011 Toyota Tacoma got 83/100 consumer ratings
- Kelley Blue Book: 2011 Toyota Tacoma got 4.5/5.0 consumer ratings
2019 Toyota Tacoma
2019 model year is considered one of the worst years for the Toyota Tacoma. Major complaints revolved around its transmission, with drivers reporting slow and clunky shifts. The infotainment system also faced criticism for being outdated. Safety ratings for this year were lower than some of its competitors.
- Common Issues:
- Low-Speed Vibration
- Jumpy Transmission
- Ratings & Reviews:
2004 Toyota Tacoma
This model faced significant issues with frame rust. Owners reported premature rusting, leading to potential safety hazards and costly repairs. Transmission problems, including difficulty shifting and gear slippage, were also common.
- Common Issues:
- Ball joint problems
- Transmission Problems
2016 Toyota Tacoma
The 2016 model year had its fair share of issues. Based on recalls and complaints, it’s considered one of the worst years for the Tacoma. Transmission problems and issues with the audio and infotainment systems were frequently reported.
- Common Issues:
- Wiring Problems
- Delayed Engagement
- Hard Shifts
Worst Year: 2012 Toyota Tacoma (3.87 Rating)
The 2012 Tacoma faced numerous engine issues. Owners reported their trucks suddenly going into limp mode, with check engine lights illuminating, and an inability to exceed certain speeds.
There were also concerns about the quality of the interior materials and reports of problems with the automatic transmission.
- Common Issues:
- Engine very weak
- Vibration while driving
- Pump assembly failure
Consumer Reviews, Ratings, Recalls & Complaints:
- NHTSA: 2012 Toyota Tacoma got 7 recalls and 282 complaints
- Edmunds: 2012 Toyota Tacoma got 4.2/5.0 consumer reviews
- Jd Power: 2012 Toyota Tacoma got 82/100 consumer ratings
- Kelley Blue Book: 2012 Toyota Tacoma got 4.7/5.0 consumer and 3.8 expert ratings
Worst Year: 2008 Toyota Tacoma (3.57 Rating)
https://youtu.be/SaNVtnLNF88
The 2008 Tacoma suffered from premature corrosion of the frame and suspension. Some drivers reported their trucks falling apart due to rust.
There were also complaints about the rear suspension, timing chain, and the quality of ride and cabin materials. Some owners even claimed that applying the brakes caused the vehicle to speed up dangerously.
- Common Issues:
- Sudden unintended acceleration
- Popping noise from the rear
- Paint chipping
Consumer Reviews, Ratings, Recalls & Complaints:
- NHTSA: 2008 Toyota Tacoma got 11 recalls and 407 complaints
- Edmunds: 2008 Toyota Tacoma got 4.4/5.0 consumer reviews
- Jd Power: 2008 Toyota Tacoma got 85/100 consumer ratings
- Kelley Blue Book: 2008 Toyota Tacoma got 4.7/5.0 consumer ratings
Worst Year: 2007 Toyota Tacoma (3.54 Rating)
The 2007 Tacoma faced issues with frame rusting, which could compromise safety. The fuel economy and handling were also criticized.
A common complaint was that the vehicle would speed up unexpectedly when the brake was applied. Others mentioned the vehicle’s paint fading badly.
- Common Issues:
- Accelerator sticking
- Clear coat problems
- Dealership repair issues
Consumer Reviews, Ratings, Recalls & Complaints:
- NHTSA: 2007 Toyota Tacoma got 10 recalls and 519 complaints
- Edmunds: 2007 Toyota Tacoma got 4.6/5.0 consumer reviews
- Jd Power: 2007 Toyota Tacoma got 83/100 consumer ratings
- Kelley Blue Book: 2007 Toyota Tacoma got 4.7/5.0 consumer ratings
Best Toyota Tacoma Years
2017 Toyota Tacoma
The 2017 Tacoma is highly regarded for its impressive features. It boasts advanced off-road capabilities, a plethora of safety features, and a user-friendly infotainment system. The cabin is spacious, and the ride quality is refined.
- Notable Features:
- Advanced off-road suspension system
- Rearview camera, blind spot monitoring, and pre-collision system
- User-friendly infotainment system with touchscreen display
2013 Toyota Tacoma
The 2013 Tacoma is a reliable and capable midsize pickup truck. It offers excellent off-road capabilities, a commendable payload capacity, and a robust towing capacity. Safety features like antilock brakes and stability control are standard.
- Best Features:
- Off-Road Capability with advanced features for enthusiasts
- Maximum payload capacity of 1,500 pounds
- Towing capacity of 6,500 pounds
2018 Toyota Tacoma
The 2018 Tacoma stands out for its new standard safety features and user-friendly infotainment system. It also offers various off-road packages, making it a favorite among off-road enthusiasts.
- Best Features:
- Updated Toyota Safety Sense-P
- Infotainment system with Apple CarPlay, Android Auto, and Amazon Alexa compatibility
- Advanced off-road packages
Best Year: 2020 Toyota Tacoma (4.75 Rating)
The 2020 Tacoma was lauded for its robust off-road capabilities, especially with the TRD Pro variant. The infotainment system received a significant upgrade, now featuring Apple CarPlay, Android Auto, and Amazon Alexa integration. The truck’s safety features, including adaptive cruise control and lane departure warning, were also praised.
- Notable Features:
- Enhanced off-road capabilities with TRD Pro
- Modern infotainment system with smartphone integration
- Advanced safety features
Consumer Reviews, Ratings, Recalls & Complaints:
- NHTSA: 2020 Toyota Tacoma got 2 recalls and 95 complaints
- Edmunds: 2020 Toyota Tacoma got 4.8/5.0 consumer reviews
- Jd Power: 2020 Toyota Tacoma got 88/100 consumer ratings
- Kelley Blue Book: 2020 Toyota Tacoma got 4.8/5.0 consumer ratings
Best Year: 2021 Toyota Tacoma (4.80 Rating)
Tacoma continued the trend of excellence with its rugged design and enhanced performance features. The truck’s towing capacity was notably impressive, and the interior boasted high-quality materials and a comfortable driving experience. The addition of a 360-degree camera was a welcome feature for many drivers.
- Best Features:
- Impressive towing capacity
- High-quality interior materials
- 360-degree camera for enhanced visibility
Consumer Reviews, Ratings, Recalls & Complaints:
- NHTSA: 2021 Toyota Tacoma got 1 recall and 80 complaints
- Edmunds: 2021 Toyota Tacoma got 4.9/5.0 consumer reviews
- Jd Power: 2021 Toyota Tacoma got 89/100 consumer ratings
- Kelley Blue Book: 2021 Toyota Tacoma got 4.9/5.0 consumer ratings
Best Year: 2022 Toyota Tacoma (4.85 Rating)
The 2022 Tacoma is the pinnacle of Toyota’s midsize truck offerings. With state-of-the-art technology features, a powerful engine lineup, and a refined interior, it’s no wonder this year’s model tops the list.
The truck’s fuel efficiency was notably better than previous years, and the addition of new color options gave buyers more customization choices.
- Best Features:
- State-of-the-art technology integrations
- Powerful and efficient engine options
- Expanded color palette for customization
Consumer Reviews, Ratings, Recalls & Complaints:
- NHTSA: 2022 Toyota Tacoma got 0 recalls and 50 complaints
- Edmunds: 2022 Toyota Tacoma got 5.0/5.0 consumer reviews
- Jd Power: 2022 Toyota Tacoma got 90/100 consumer ratings
- Kelley Blue Book: 2022 Toyota Tacoma got 5.0/5.0 consumer ratings
Toyota Tacoma: A Journey Through Time
The Early Years: Establishing a Legacy
The Toyota Tacoma made its debut in the mid-1990s, replacing the Toyota Hilux in the U.S. market. These early models were compact, reliable, and quickly gained a reputation for their durability and off-road capabilities.
- Notable Features:
- Compact design suitable for city driving
- Reliable 4-cylinder engines
- Affordable maintenance and parts
Consumer Reviews, Ratings, Recalls & Complaints:
- NHTSA: Early Toyota Tacoma models had minimal recalls
- Edmunds: Early models received 4.5/5.0 consumer reviews on average
- Jd Power: Early models averaged 85/100 consumer ratings
- Kelley Blue Book: Early models averaged 4.7/5.0 consumer ratings
The 2000s: Embracing Modernity
As the new millennium dawned, Tacoma underwent significant changes. It transitioned from a compact to a midsize truck, offering more space, power, and features. The 2000s also saw the introduction of the TRD (Toyota Racing Development) variants, catering to off-road enthusiasts.
- Best Features:
- Introduction of V6 engines
- Enhanced safety features like ABS and airbags
- TRD variants for off-road enthusiasts
Consumer Reviews, Ratings, Recalls & Complaints:
- NHTSA: Mid-2000s models had varying recalls, with some years facing more issues than others
- Edmunds: Mid-2000s models averaged 4.6/5.0 consumer reviews
- Jd Power: Mid-2000s models averaged 87/100 consumer ratings
- Kelley Blue Book: Mid-2000s models averaged 4.8/5.0 consumer ratings
The 2010s: Setting Industry Standards
A golden era for the Tacoma. With competitors stepping up their game, Toyota ensured the Tacoma remained at the forefront with technological advancements, enhanced safety features, and a focus on comfort without compromising its rugged nature.
- Best Features:
- Advanced infotainment systems with smartphone integration
- Enhanced safety features like adaptive cruise control and lane departure warning
- Refined interiors with quality materials
Consumer Reviews, Ratings, Recalls & Complaints:
- NHTSA: Late 2010s models had fewer recalls compared to earlier years
- Edmunds: Late 2010s models received 4.8/5.0 consumer reviews on average
- Jd Power: Late 2010s models averaged 89/100 consumer ratings
- Kelley Blue Book: Late 2010s models averaged 4.9/5.0 consumer ratings
FAQ
1. What is the towing capacity of the Toyota Tacoma?
While the article covers various aspects of the Tacoma’s performance, it doesn’t specify towing capacities. Generally, the towing capacity varies based on the model year and configuration, but recent Tacoma models can tow up to 6,800 pounds when properly equipped.
2. How does it compare to its competitors in terms of price?
The article delves deep into the Tacoma’s performance and history but doesn’t touch on its price comparison.
Typically, the Tacoma is competitively priced within its segment, often offering more standard features than some competitors.
3. Are there any hybrid or electric versions of the Toyota Tacoma available?
While the article mentions Toyota’s exploration of hybrid options in 2020, it doesn’t specify if a hybrid or electric model has been released.
As of the last update, Toyota has shown interest in hybrid technology for the Tacoma, but specific models would need further research.
4. How does the Toyota Tacoma fare in terms of resale value?
The Tacoma’s reputation for reliability and ruggedness often translates to strong resale values, though the article doesn’t provide specific figures.
5. What are the common maintenance costs?
While the article touches on some issues faced by the Tacoma in certain years, it doesn’t provide a detailed breakdown of maintenance costs. Generally, the Tacoma is known for its durability, which can lead to lower maintenance costs over time.
6. How has the Toyota Tacoma’s fuel efficiency evolved over the years?
The article mentions the MPG debate in 2019 and Toyota’s focus on fuel efficiency in 2020. However, a year-by-year breakdown isn’t provided. Historically, the Tacoma has made strides in improving its fuel efficiency, especially in recent years.
Final Words
The Toyota Tacoma’s journey, spanning decades, is a testament to Toyota’s commitment to innovation, reliability, and customer satisfaction. From its peak years showcasing unparalleled performance to the challenging times that tested its mettle, the Tacoma has emerged stronger, adapting to the evolving needs of its diverse user base.
Whether you’re a potential buyer, a Tacoma enthusiast, or someone keen on automotive history, understanding this truck’s legacy offers valuable insights into what makes a vehicle truly iconic. As we drive into the future, the Tacoma’s story serves as a beacon, illuminating the path of resilience, evolution, and excellence.
